This recipe started out as a recipe from Paula Deen. I saw it many years ago and thought it would be a great addition to my
family's Easter Brunch menu. I made it and it was a
HUGE hit. Actually, the first year I made it, I thought, "well, I'll just see if anyone likes it." It was gone in a matter of minutes and everyone said 'You only made ONE? What were you thinking??" LOL So now I make TWO of them every year for our Brunch. Love it.
But here's the thing.. over the years, I've sort of tweaked the recipe a little bit here and there, so it's still basically the same, but now I've rewritten it below to include a few of my tweaks. I think this year's brunch was the best ever!
The biggest problem I found was that the fresh tomatoes were too juicy. All that extra moisture just made a soggy pie. No matter what I did, I couldn't find the right solution. Even though the original recipe said to salt them and let them drain for ten minutes. I would let them drain for an hour or longer.. Still too soggy. I diced them instead of slicing them. Still too soggy. So then I decided to try and thicken it a little. I added a sprinkle of flour. Hmmm... better, but not the answer. Still too soggy.
Then it finally came to me. This year, I decided to ROAST the tomatoes first. Boom! This was the ah ha moment! Not only would it greatly reduce the amount of moisture, but it would also concentrate the tomato flavor. WIN WIN! Now I think this recipe is where it needed to be! Sometimes I think it's good to revisit a recipe now and then and tweak it to suit our ever changing tastes, dontcha think?
BTW, even though I changed Paula's recipe, I still kept her picture.
Why? because it's nice and I like it!
4 or 5 medium tomatoes
a few tbs of oil
salt and pepper
pinch or two of sugar
10 fresh basil leaves, chopped
3 scallions, chopped
2 tbs flour
1 (9-inch) prebaked deep dish pie shell
1 cup grated mozzarella
1 cup grated cheddar
1/2 cup mayonnaise
Heat oven to 350ºF.
Slice each tomato horizontally into 4 or 5 thick slices. In other words, if the tomato is standing with the stem end on top, slice it sideways. Place them on a parchment lined baking sheet. Drizzle with a little oil, then sprinkle with salt, pepper, and sugar. Roast in the oven until most of the liquid has evaporated and tomatoes are soft. Scoop them off the tray to a cutting board, and roughly chop them. Add them to a mixing bowl with your chopped scallions, basil, and 2 tbs flour. Gently toss to combine. Place your tomato mixture in your previously blind baked pie crust. Using the same mixing bowl, stir together the cheeses and mayo. (I find it's easier to do this with my hands, not unlike one mixes ground beef).
Spread your cheese mixture over your tomato mixture. Bake in oven for about 30-45 minutes or until the cheese is melted and starts to brown on top. Let it cool slightly. Serve warm or at room temperature.
Tips:
If I don't have time to blind bake the crust, I just crank the heat up and bake the whole thing at 400º. That helps to cook the crust before the filling.
Update!
It seems that every time I make this, I do it differently. This time, I played around with the amounts of the ingredients and I thought I'd approach it the same way I'd make a fruit pie.
I always use a deep Pyrex pie dish and I wanted it to be more full, so I roasted two whole sheet trays of tomatoes. I sliced my Roma tomatoes into thick slices, then placed them on parchment lined sheet trays, sprinkled with a little salt, pepper, and a little sugar. Roasted them in a 425º over until most of the juices evaporated. Then I chopped them up and placed them in a big bowl with chopped scallions and basil. Full disclosure, I was out of fresh basil leaves, so I used the basil paste that comes in a tube. Added a couple tbs of flour, then stirred it all together. Poured it into my already blind baked crust, then moved on to the cheese topping. I used probably 2-1 Mozzarella to Cheddar, and I only added about 2 tbs of mayonnaise. I also added a little bit more of the basil paste, then stirred it together and spooned it on top of the pie over the tomatoes, then baked it as usual. BOOM. .... There was literally NONE left...!
I'm not saying this one was the BEST one I've ever made.. but I'm also not NOT saying it!!!